MCEA Blog

MCEA Staff blog regularly about current environmental issues and how they relate to MCEA's work.
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Meet Our Staff
    • Meet Our Board >
      • Alexandra Klass
      • Halston Sleets
    • MCEA in the News
    • Job Openings
    • Financials
  • Issues
    • Water >
      • 25 by '25 Water Quality Goal
      • Water Pollution >
        • Agriculture
        • Septic Systems
        • Urban Stormwater Run-Off
        • Point Source Pollution
      • Condition of Minnesota's Waters
      • Clean Water Accountability Act >
        • TMDLs
    • Land Use & Transportation >
      • Transportation >
        • Transitway Maps
      • Land Use
      • Gentrification Typology
    • Clean Energy >
      • Promoting Clean Energy
      • Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions
      • Pipelines
      • Air Quality
    • Natural Resources >
      • Aquatic Invasive Species
      • Drainage
      • Great Lakes
      • Shoreland
      • In the Courtroom >
        • Historic MCEA Legal Victories
      • Wetlands
      • Buffers
    • Mining >
      • Sulfide Mining
      • Mining Maps
  • At The Legislature
    • MCEA Bill Tracker
    • Sign On Letters
    • Fact Sheets
  • RegenerateMN
  • Events
    • Legally Green
  • Publications
    • Newsletter Archive
  • MCEA GIS Maps
    • GIS Research
    • Educational Maps
    • Interactive Maps
  • supportus
  • Contact Us
  • Blog
  • Take Action
    • Serve on a Committee
    • Volunteer with MCEA
  • About Us
  • I Make This Possible
  • Donate
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Meet Our Staff
    • Meet Our Board >
      • Alexandra Klass
      • Halston Sleets
    • MCEA in the News
    • Job Openings
    • Financials
  • Issues
    • Water >
      • 25 by '25 Water Quality Goal
      • Water Pollution >
        • Agriculture
        • Septic Systems
        • Urban Stormwater Run-Off
        • Point Source Pollution
      • Condition of Minnesota's Waters
      • Clean Water Accountability Act >
        • TMDLs
    • Land Use & Transportation >
      • Transportation >
        • Transitway Maps
      • Land Use
      • Gentrification Typology
    • Clean Energy >
      • Promoting Clean Energy
      • Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions
      • Pipelines
      • Air Quality
    • Natural Resources >
      • Aquatic Invasive Species
      • Drainage
      • Great Lakes
      • Shoreland
      • In the Courtroom >
        • Historic MCEA Legal Victories
      • Wetlands
      • Buffers
    • Mining >
      • Sulfide Mining
      • Mining Maps
  • At The Legislature
    • MCEA Bill Tracker
    • Sign On Letters
    • Fact Sheets
  • RegenerateMN
  • Events
    • Legally Green
  • Publications
    • Newsletter Archive
  • MCEA GIS Maps
    • GIS Research
    • Educational Maps
    • Interactive Maps
  • supportus
  • Contact Us
  • Blog
  • Take Action
    • Serve on a Committee
    • Volunteer with MCEA
  • About Us
  • I Make This Possible
  • Donate

Dollars & Nonsense, Part 1

1/12/2017

0 Comments

 
WRITTEN BY: Jim Erkel, MCEA Land Use & Transportation Director
The legislature is back in session, and it will revisit funding for transportation following its chaotic fail at the end of last session. The means by which we fund transportation are complicated, and sometimes difficult to understand. In fact, it is complicated enough that legislators on the transportation committees are starting the session with tutorials on funding mechanisms from the staff at MNDOT and the Metropolitan Council.

The black-box character of how transportation is funded lends itself to a number of talking points that push the discussion, but some of them are either not true, stretch the truth, or need a substantial amount of context to be properly understood. 

This is the first post in my blog series called "Dollars & Nonsense." Each post will take a transportation funding issue, or talking point, and I will walk through the policies behind it, look at the numbers, and provide background to better grasp the complexities of transportation policy in Minnesota.
Picture
We will start small with a look at how Minnesota's main user fees -- the state's gas tax and Metro Transit's fares -- have kept up with the cost of maintaining and operating roads and transit systems. We will work our way up to big ones, like 'roads pay for themselves; transit is heavily subsidized' and 'the road needs of Greater Minnesota has been neglected.'

Transit critics point out that farebox recovery only covers between 25%-30% of the cost of Metro Transit's operations (note that Metro Transit has not increased fares since 2008) and argue that fares should be raised to reflect the increased costs of operation. As a rule, it is reasonable to expect that user fees will be periodically adjusted to reflect changes in the costs of operation. However, what is good for the goose is also good for the gander. The state's gas tax was last increased in 2008. 

In the graphic below, we compare how the user fees have changed since 1988, the last time the state's gas tax was raised before 2008. You will see that the gas tax has been raised only once, while transit fares have been adjusted 10 times. Compared to several measures, transit fares have more than kept up with inflation, and it is the state's gas tax that has failed to keep up with increased costs of operation.
Picture
If the gas tax had increased at the same rate as Metro Transit's base fare, we would be paying 40.1 cents per gallon, not 28.5 cents per gallon. Using the rule of thumb that one cent of Minnesota's gas tax raises $30 million per year, the difference of 11.6 cents translates into roughly $348 million per year. That's more than the statutory dedication of sales tax on auto parts and repair to roads proposed by House Republicans last session.

​Rather than raiding the general fund and re-directing monies that support issues such as health care and education, road interests should commit to the principle articulated by transit critics, and raise their user fee to reflect the higher costs of operations. Transit already has. 
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    May 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016

    Categories

    All
    Mining

    RSS Feed

Picture


​Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy
1919 University Ave W, Suite 515 | Saint Paul, MN 55104

Office Hours
Monday-Friday, 8:00 AM-4:30 PM

​BOARD MEMBER LOGIN

Connect with us on social media

Telephone
651-223-5969

Email MCEA

Photos used under Creative Commons from briandjan607, vastateparksstaff, berriehol, kelvinf19, Wimox, Office of Governor Mark Dayton & Lt. Governor Tina, auntjojo, Darth Bengal, Marufish, Iburiedpaul, Iburiedpaul, Tony Webster, @the.photoguy (insta), Iburiedpaul, briandjan607, TheNoxid
  ​Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Meet Our Staff
    • Meet Our Board >
      • Alexandra Klass
      • Halston Sleets
    • MCEA in the News
    • Job Openings
    • Financials
  • Issues
    • Water >
      • 25 by '25 Water Quality Goal
      • Water Pollution >
        • Agriculture
        • Septic Systems
        • Urban Stormwater Run-Off
        • Point Source Pollution
      • Condition of Minnesota's Waters
      • Clean Water Accountability Act >
        • TMDLs
    • Land Use & Transportation >
      • Transportation >
        • Transitway Maps
      • Land Use
      • Gentrification Typology
    • Clean Energy >
      • Promoting Clean Energy
      • Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions
      • Pipelines
      • Air Quality
    • Natural Resources >
      • Aquatic Invasive Species
      • Drainage
      • Great Lakes
      • Shoreland
      • In the Courtroom >
        • Historic MCEA Legal Victories
      • Wetlands
      • Buffers
    • Mining >
      • Sulfide Mining
      • Mining Maps
  • At The Legislature
    • MCEA Bill Tracker
    • Sign On Letters
    • Fact Sheets
  • RegenerateMN
  • Events
    • Legally Green
  • Publications
    • Newsletter Archive
  • MCEA GIS Maps
    • GIS Research
    • Educational Maps
    • Interactive Maps
  • supportus
  • Contact Us
  • Blog
  • Take Action
    • Serve on a Committee
    • Volunteer with MCEA
  • About Us
  • I Make This Possible
  • Donate
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Meet Our Staff
    • Meet Our Board >
      • Alexandra Klass
      • Halston Sleets
    • MCEA in the News
    • Job Openings
    • Financials
  • Issues
    • Water >
      • 25 by '25 Water Quality Goal
      • Water Pollution >
        • Agriculture
        • Septic Systems
        • Urban Stormwater Run-Off
        • Point Source Pollution
      • Condition of Minnesota's Waters
      • Clean Water Accountability Act >
        • TMDLs
    • Land Use & Transportation >
      • Transportation >
        • Transitway Maps
      • Land Use
      • Gentrification Typology
    • Clean Energy >
      • Promoting Clean Energy
      • Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions
      • Pipelines
      • Air Quality
    • Natural Resources >
      • Aquatic Invasive Species
      • Drainage
      • Great Lakes
      • Shoreland
      • In the Courtroom >
        • Historic MCEA Legal Victories
      • Wetlands
      • Buffers
    • Mining >
      • Sulfide Mining
      • Mining Maps
  • At The Legislature
    • MCEA Bill Tracker
    • Sign On Letters
    • Fact Sheets
  • RegenerateMN
  • Events
    • Legally Green
  • Publications
    • Newsletter Archive
  • MCEA GIS Maps
    • GIS Research
    • Educational Maps
    • Interactive Maps
  • supportus
  • Contact Us
  • Blog
  • Take Action
    • Serve on a Committee
    • Volunteer with MCEA
  • About Us
  • I Make This Possible
  • Donate
Live Chat Support ×

Connecting

You: ::content::
::agent_name:: ::content::
::content::
::content::